Mystery Regular Tee
Mystery Regular Tee
Mystery Regular Tee
Mystery Regular Tee


Mystery Regular Tee

All of our second hand tees are selected to be cool and have certain qualities. They are from the 70's , 80's 90's and Early 2000's. They can't all be old but many of them are. Think of it as a lottery that you can't lose. For a guaranteed old Tee please see our premium Vintage Tees.

Prices reflect our ability to get them. Smaller sizes are more rare so we have to charge more.

We are always attempting to lower our prices, so keep tuning in.

Tell us your size and we will hand select a perfectly broken-in tee just for you!

For special requests on theme, color, etc or on types of tees we should avoid when sending please make a note in the style preferences when placing your order. We cannot guarantee we will be able to satisfy your request (but we will try our best!). 

100% Satisfaction Guaranteed!

If you receive yours and are dissatisfied in ANY way, please email and we will do our best to optimize your experience. 

Thank you for shopping with us! 



Read More

All of these amazing thrift goodies are sized by Tagpop Standards. We do not go by the size on the labels rather when we get the clothes in we sort them from small to xxxl. Meaning- an old tshirt could have an XL label but still be a small because of its age and how many times it's been washed. If you are a woman please consider Flannels and Tees as men's sizes.

FREE Shipping for all orders over $40
Regular shipping: Calculated by postal rate.
Free Shipping for orders over $100
Regular shipping: $20 for orders below $100
Free shipping for orders over $100
Regular Shipping: $35 for orders below $100



We are an eco-friendly company with a unique exchange policy that is more cost effective for you, our customer, and better for the environment:

For All Regular Mystery Items:

  • You are allowed up to 3 exchanges
  • You do not have to pay to ship the goods back to us; simply donate them at any clothing charity, and provide receipt of donation, see our donation page for more info!
  • Email, with your proof of donation photo and we will send you a code for a new TagPop Mystery Regular Item
    • If you do not wish to donate, simply email us
  • When you checkout, you will only pay shipping one way (rather than both ways), AND you’ll get a new good for the shipping of the exchange, the item is free of charge.

For All Premium Products

  • You are allowed unlimited exchanges
  • Ship the item to TagPop 111 Water ST New Haven, CT 06511
  • We will issue you a new product once we receive the old one

 Refund Policy

For every order, we do not issue refunds on shipping cost. 

We provide refunds only for items that have failed our sorting process and have the following characteristics.

  • Multiple stains (more than two)
  • Damaged beyond wear and tear (please note that some damage, as is the case with Premium Vintage tees, is considered desirable and additive to value)
  • If your tee shirt is one of the following brands (or fast fashion)
    • Old Navy
    • Hollister
    • Forever 21
    • Aeropostale
    • Abercrombie
    • American Eagle
  • Offensive or undesirable Graphic (this is grounds for an exchange, but we may make exceptions if this garment would have otherwise been sorted out by us)

If you wish to pursue a refund, you must provide a photo of the garment , and email us at

Style Preferences

Email us at to provide as much info on what you love in terms of style, color, and themes

Please feel free to provide additional feedback in our survey here

For questions about anything at all (or to say hi), please email and we will get back to you ASAP.